Snorkl AI for Spanish and Math Review: The Ethical Concerns
Over the summer, both the Math and Spanish review teams decided to switch from alternative methods of testing students' skill retention to Snorkl AI. Because Sequoyah typically enrolls students in Math and Spanish for only one semester a year, it is important to have a program in place that keeps students' skills fresh even when they are not currently in a math or Spanish class. But Snorkl in particular uses AI to grade students' work, which has sparked a debate surrounding ethical concerns.
Bradley Immel, the math teacher and head of math review, along with the administration, decided to implement this program instead of Khan Academy, which was used in previous years. He believes that Snorkl is beneficial to students as it gives them thorough feedback on their work rather than just telling them if their work is right or wrong. Sequoyah is piloting this program to see how well students retain their mathematical knowledge during the semester in which they are not enrolled in math classes. However, Immel is aware of the ethical concerns it raises.
When one student came to him regarding their ethical objection to using AI in their schoolwork, Immel gave them an exception to review their work one-on-one during office hours. “If I were to do that for 10 or 20 or 30 students, I wouldn't have time to also do office hours for Functions and Transformations” says Immel. He wants to cater to students who do not feel comfortable using this program, but is concerned about keeping time for advisees and other students who need his immediate attention.
Stephen Marchand, Spanish teacher and head of Spanish review, only joined the Sequoyah community this semester, so he does not have much past experience dealing with Spanish review. Marchand believes that using Snorkl is helpful to students in lower Spanish levels because it gives students feedback on basic skills such as conjugations and vocab words. “With Snorkl, what we tried to do is to give that independence to the students, so they wouldn't have to meet at school,” says Marchand. Using this program allows students to use advisory time for office hours rather than the tertulias option that was available last year.
In tertulias, a large group of students would spend one advisory a week working with a Spanish teacher and doing group exercises that relied on human interaction to test students' Spanish speaking. Now, with Snorkl, the idea is that students can complete the assignments on their own time over the span of a bit under a month rather than having to lose a study hall or office hours period weekly. However, this takes away the important aspect of human interaction that tertulias gave us.
Freya McCoy ’29 actively tries to avoid AI in her day-to-day life, so the obligation to submit assignments to an AI platform goes against her morals. McCoy stated her stance on this issue to Immel, and she received a special exception to simply send emails to him instead of getting feedback from Snorkl. She believes that using technology that harms our environment further is completely unnecessary and avoidable. “We actively know that it is hurting the environment, and I'm not gonna add to that. And I think that having it required is the bad part,” says McCoy.
Although it is just a pilot program at the moment, teachers using Snorkl are raising issues for students who actively try to avoid artificial intelligence whenever possible. On the other hand, Snorkl is efficient and helpful for teachers who are already overwhelmed by their workload. As AI becomes more interwoven into our everyday lives, we must acknowledge its effects on both the students and teachers at our school. Having more options for students who are against using this program should be a priority so students can keep their freedom to choose when they are and are not comfortable using AI.